Watch The Kitchen Table
Illustration · A wooded trail in late November, with an old stone wall and a stump to rest on. Not drawn from a photograph.

Bedford Hills and on the road · 1944–1955

The quarter mile

Sober and famous, he fell into a depression that lasted, on and off, for eleven years. He fought it a quarter mile at a time.

“I used to be ashamed of my condition and didn’t talk about it. But in recent years, I freely confess I’m a depressive, and that attracts other depressives to me.”

Bill W., in a letter to someone who had written to him about depression · quoted in Pass It On, 1984

Eleven years

In January 1944 Bill and Lois came home from a three-month tour of the groups in the West, a triumph by Pass It On’s account. Almost at once he fell into a depression “so black that its effect on him was more debilitating than a physical assault.” For long stretches he couldn’t get out of bed, and Lois made sure he ate. “An awful lot of people believed he was drinking,” Marty M. remembered. Lois admitted, “I wasn’t too sympathetic, actually.”

He tried everything he could think of. In 1944 he began seeing a psychiatrist, Dr. Harry Tiebout. An osteopath found what Bill called “a lesion in my spine near the base of the skull,” and gave him “a tremendous lift.” He cut his sugar to a third, took a little thyroid, and later tried “B-12, male hormones, ACE and the like.” By about 1949 he was seeing a second therapist on Fridays and taking instruction in Catholicism from Monsignor Fulton Sheen on Saturdays. Pass It On names the therapist Frances Weekes; one AA history timeline identifies her as Frances Wickes, a New York analyst of Carl Jung’s school.

What he kept coming back to was walking: a quarter mile at a time, counting his steps against his breath. On good days he walked five miles on the wooded trails around Bedford Hills. He blamed himself for not working the Steps well enough, and many members told him the same.

In the spring of 1946 he canceled every engagement and went with Lois to an old farmhouse near Brattleboro, Vermont. About ten days in, while she read to him, he went “quiet.” It was as if the car had been put in neutral, he wrote, “But — this is very important — the engine was still running.”

A red barn in the Vermont countryside, in a color slide.
A Vermont barn, in a color slide from 1962. In the spring of 1946 Bill and Lois went to an old farmhouse near Brattleboro; this isn’t it.Edmund L. Mitchell Collection, Boston Public Library

Back at work, he set out to make AA’s trustees answerable to a conference elected by the groups. Most of the trustees were against it, and he fought them with what he later called “sledgehammer tactics” and “blistering memorandums.” Looking back, he said he had been “on a dry bender of the worst possible sort.” Some of the alcoholic trustees, he wrote, “darkly murmured that I must have gone crazy.” In 1948 Dr. Bob wrote to him that “Easy Does It” seemed the best course.

In 1951 and 1952 he wrote Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions while, as Pass It On puts it, “suffering almost constant depression.” On January 24, 1954, their wedding anniversary, Lois had a heart attack. Bill wrote to Father Dowling that she had been “grass-widowed by A.A. May God forgive my part in all this.” On February 2 he turned down an honorary degree from Yale, and on February 14 his father died.

At St. Louis in July 1955 he handed AA over to its members. As he spoke, he said later, “for a moment I dreaded the coming change as much as anyone.” Pass It On says the depression lifted after 1955. Yet in 1956, back from a trip west “in a state of almost complete collapse,” he heard that his old East Dorset friend Mark Whalon had died. “This all hit me so hard that I got into a hysteria and felt that I simply couldn’t face it.”

Listen The quarter mile About 1 minute

His remedy, in his words

Walk a quarter mile

People wrote to Bill about their own depressions, and he wrote back about his. This was what he did on the bad days. Press Start to walk it with him at an ordinary pace: about 500 steps, about five minutes, six steps breathing in and four breathing out.

His words, from those letters, as Pass It On quotes them (chapter 18). It’s his history, told as he told it, not medical advice. The walk has no sound, and stops whenever you like.

  1. Setting out

    “I would set myself a small stint. I would determine to walk and breathe for a quarter of a mile.”

  2. A third of the way

    “Lots of times, I had to beat myself to do even this much.”

  3. Two thirds of the way

    “But I had learned that the penalty of quitting entirely — just looking at the wall — was far greater.”

  4. A quarter mile

    “So I would do the quarter mile. Having done this, I found that I could go on, maybe a half mile more.”

Eleven years

Pass It On’s authors: “It’s probably not coincidental that the years of Bill’s depressions — 1944-1955 — were also the years when he did the most exhausting and intensive work for A.A.” His secretary, Nell Wing, put it more simply: “It baffled him.”

For a closer look

Go deeper

What the people around him thought was wrong, two answers to who can belong, and the honors he turned down.

What was wrong?

The people around him didn’t agree. Al M., in Los Angeles, joked that the tour had shown Bill “we didn’t need him — all we needed was his book.” Dr. Jack Norris, a nonalcoholic trustee and a physician, thought it was partly physical: “You can’t separate an organic depression from a psychological depression.” Dr. Earl M., a psychiatrist and a friend: “I felt that he had no one he could talk with about his far-out spiritual ideas.” Tom P., who later helped him write: “the depressions were largely exhaustion — I mean spiritual exhaustion.”

One more view comes from outside AA’s own books. Francis Hartigan, who was Lois’s secretary in her last years, reports that Tom P. also tied it to guilt: that Bill felt like a fraud writing about honesty while he was having affairs. That is one witness’s reading, and Tom P. later broke with Bill. The other women are part of the story in 7 · Mr. Anonymous.

Bill himself blamed his failure to work the Steps, his glands, and in time his position: a therapist told him, about 1949, that his role in AA was at war with his needs as a person.

Who can belong?

In a 1943 letter Bill accepted segregated groups as a practical matter. “The prejudice is so great that 50 white men might stay away from A.A. in order that we save one colored. That’s the principle of the greatest good for the greatest number. It falls grievously short of our ideal,” he wrote, and he added that he was still looking hard for an answer. He told groups to follow the wishes of their members, and if a group turned Black alcoholics away socially, to make “a superhuman effort” to help each one start a group of his own.

In 1945 Barry L., on duty at a Manhattan clubhouse, telephoned Bill about a newcomer: a Black man and an ex-convict who carried everything he owned on his back, wore makeup, and said he used drugs. The members didn’t know what to do. Bill asked Barry to go over the list again. Then: “did you say he was a drunk?” Barry said there was no question about it. “Well, I think that’s all we can ask,” said Bill.

Pass It On calls the case a precedent for the Third Tradition: the only requirement for AA membership is a desire to stop drinking.

Degrees declined
A color postcard of a stone courtyard at Yale University, with a tall Gothic tower beyond.
Branford Court and Harkness Tower, Yale University, on a postcard from about 1930 to 1945.Tichnor Brothers Collection, Boston Public Library

Bill said he turned down six honorary degrees. The best known is Yale’s Doctor of Laws, which he declined in a letter of February 2, 1954: “the dread neurotic germ of the power contagion has survived in me also.” He asked the people who knew not to talk about it. “I don’t want to capitalize on humility.”

He also turned down a Time cover, with the back of his head on it, and the cover story that went with it, though he thought the story might have brought AA a thousand members. Lois said he “took every opportunity reasonable to exaggerate his own defects.”

Sources
  • Pass It On. AA World Services, 1984. Chapters 18 to 22, quoting Bill’s letters, Lois, Marty M., Nell Wing, Dr. Jack Norris, Dr. Earl M., Tom P. and Barry L.
  • Alcoholics Anonymous Comes of Age. AA World Services, 1957. Bill on the trustees, and on St. Louis, 1955.
  • Francis Hartigan. Bill W. St. Martin’s Press, 2000. On Tom P. and the depression, as reported online; not yet checked against the book.
  • On Frances Wickes: “A Narrative Timeline of A.A. History,” silkworth.net. One source; not yet checked further.
  • A Vermont barn (color slide, 1962), Edmund L. Mitchell Collection, Boston Public Library. No known copyright restrictions.
  • Branford Court and Harkness Tower, Yale University, New Haven, Conn. (postcard, about 1930–45), Tichnor Brothers Collection, Boston Public Library. No known copyright restrictions.