Watch The Kitchen Table
Illustration · An imagined parish hall set up for a Cana Conference in the 1940s: chairs in pairs around a small table with a question box and cups set in twos, and a coffee urn at the side. Not drawn from a photograph.

St. Louis and New York · 1941–1949

Couples are not alone

He took the Twelve Steps to married couples, couldn’t take a seat on AA’s board, and answered Bill W.’s letters through a year of Catholic lessons.

“I believe there is a priesthood of husband to wife and wife to husband.”

Father Ed to Bill W., September 8, 1947 · as Glenn C. quotes it, 2015

Two by two

On December 7, 1941, the day of Pearl Harbor, Father Ed was walking along a street in St. Louis, afraid that his city’s young AA group would drink over the news as so many of his friends already had. A member sober less than a year fell in beside him and talked mostly about AA. Asked how he could say nothing about Pearl Harbor, the man answered, as Bill W. told the story twenty years later: “Each and every one of us in AA has already had his own private Pearl Harbor.”

Three weeks later Father Ed spent New Year’s Day with Bill and Lois W. at Stepping Stones, their new house north of New York City. He wrote to Bill afterward to thank Lois for “seconding your efforts” to make it “one of the happiest I’ve ever spent.” In February Bill asked him to become a trustee of the Alcoholic Foundation, AA’s board. He asked his provincial, the head of his Jesuit province, who told him that a post that important would need a bishop. And when rumors in Cleveland about the founders’ royalties on the Big Book left Bill wondering whether to take them at all, it was Father Ed who told him to; Legacy, in By the Carload, tells it.

He thought married couples could help each other the way alcoholics did. In 1942, AA’s newsletter Box 4-5-9 says, he started the Cana Conferences: days of talks and discussion for husbands and wives. Cana was the wedding feast in John’s Gospel; the newsletter spells the name out too, as “Couples Are Not Alone,” and says he spoke at a Cana Conference once a month, using the Twelve Steps, for the rest of his life. Who started Cana is less certain than that (see Go deeper).

In St. Louis, on January 24, 1945, five Black alcoholics formed the AA-1 Group, which Glenn C. counts as the first Black AA group anywhere. That October their secretary, Torrence S., wrote to New York that a compromise had kept them out of the white meetings but let them start their own. Glenn C. believes Father Ed “undoubtedly played an important role” in winning even that much. Nothing on hand says what he did.

Fulton and Grace Oursler, friends of the Wilsons, had introduced Bill to Monsignor Fulton J. Sheen, the radio priest, who offered to explain Catholicism to him. By the fall of 1947 Bill was going to him on Saturdays, as he would for the better part of a year, and writing to Father Ed about it. Their letters are set out in Letters, 1947.

Listen Couples are not alone About 1 minute

Bill’s Catholic lessons

Letters, 1947

Bill W. took instruction in the Catholic faith from Monsignor Fulton J. Sheen on Saturdays for the better part of a year, and wrote to Father Ed about what he was learning. Here are their letters, Bill’s on one side and Father Ed’s on the other.

Bill’s letters are quoted in Pass It On (1984). Father Ed’s reach us through Robert Fitzgerald’s The Soul of Sponsorship (Hazelden, 1995), which we haven’t seen, as Glenn C. quotes them in his 2015 draft. The two disagree on the date of Bill’s first letter, and Pass It On also has Bill at his Saturday lessons in 1949. Quotations are short excerpts.

  1. September 1947

    Bill W. to Father Ed

    “Oh, if the church only had a fellow-traveler department, a cozy spot where one could warm his hands at the fire and bite off only as much as he could swallow.”

    A postscript. Pass It On dates the letter September 9; Glenn C. has September 3.

  2. September 8, 1947

    Father Ed to Bill W.

    “As for other priestly functions, Lois is the important key to the solution of your worries these days. Give her my love.”

    Husband and wife, he wrote, are the ministers of their own marriage.

  3. Later in September

    Bill W. to Father Ed

    “I don’t see how an ex-drunk could be scandalized about anything.”

    What bothered him, he went on, was that the Church seemed unable to confess its own sins.

  4. Undated

    Bill W. to Monsignor Sheen

    “…with each passing day, I feel more like a Catholic and reason more like a Protestant!”

  5. October 1, 1947

    Father Ed to Bill W.

    “…it does not mean that the teaching body of the Church will talk horse sense but that it is protected from formally teaching moral nonsense.”

    On papal infallibility.

  6. November 26, 1947

    Father Ed to Bill W.

    “I think you may be a protestant, spelled with a small p, which is happy, but semi.”

    He had just told Bill that he doubted he really thought like a Protestant.

  7. 1948

    Bill W. to his friend Clem L.

    “They survive because of their spirituality and in spite of their infallibility.”

    On the great religions.

  8. April 15, 1948

    Father Ed to Bill W.

    “…anyone who sincerely tries to apply the 12 steps is following in Christ’s footsteps…”

He never asked

Father Ed argued for his Church’s teaching, and Bill never joined it. Ten years on Bill wrote: “It is characteristic that he has never, in all these years, asked me to join his church.”

For a closer look

Go deeper

Who started Cana, why he couldn’t be a trustee, and what he wrote for the Big Book’s jacket.

Who started Cana?

AA’s newsletter says he started the Cana Conferences in 1942. Robert Fitzgerald wrote in 1991 that in 1942 Father Ed told Bill he had started a national movement for married couples to help each other through the Steps, and Glenn C. writes that he set up the first gathering in St. Louis “in or before 1942” and devised the name.

But the encyclopedia Glenn C. himself cites says Cana began in New York in 1943, with a retreat given to eleven couples by another Jesuit, John P. Delaney. Cana spread fast, and at a Cana convention in August 1948 a Chicago couple and a South Bend couple met who went on to found the Christian Family Movement. When Father Ed died, the Grapevine called Cana “A favorite undertaking which he founded.”

The trustee who couldn’t be

The Alcoholic Foundation, set up in 1938, was AA’s board, and most of its trustees had to be non-alcoholics. On February 3, 1942, a month after their New Year’s Day together, Bill asked Father Ed to be one of them.

On February 18 Father Ed wrote back. He had asked his provincial for permission, and was told that for a post as important as that one it would have to be a bishop, not a priest. Glenn C. thinks the seat would have given him a real say in how AA’s office was run. Glenn C. adds that no bishop knew AA well enough to take it.

On the jacket

Beginning with its ninth printing, in January 1946, the Big Book’s dust jacket carried a few lines from him: “God resists the proud, assists the humble. The shortest cut to humility is humiliations, which A.A. has in abundance.” AA’s newsletter thinks that is where most members first heard his name.

He ended with a suggestion: “Non-alcoholics should read the last nine words of 12th step, page 72.” In the first edition those words are “and to practice these principles in all our affairs.” The Twelve Steps, he thought, worked on more than alcohol.

Sources
  • Pass It On. AA World Services, 1984. Chapter 16 (Bill’s instruction with Monsignor Sheen, and his letters of 1947 and 1948).
  • The Language of the Heart. AA Grapevine, 1988. Bill W., “This Matter of Fear” (January 1962), the Pearl Harbor story; “The Clergy” (September 1957); and “To Father Ed—Godspeed!” (June 1960), on Cana.
  • Glenn C., Father Ed Dowling: Bill Wilson’s Sponsor. Draft of May 1, 2015, posted in his archive at Indiana University South Bend. Chapters 1 and 2 (Cana and the Christian Family Movement), chapter 26 (New Year’s Day 1942 and the trustee letters), chapter 28 (the dust jacket and Monsignor Sheen) and chapter 29 (the 1947 and 1948 letters, quoted from Robert Fitzgerald, The Soul of Sponsorship, Hazelden, 1995). Quotations are from the online text.
  • “Father Ed Dowling — Bill W.’s Confidant and Friend.” Box 4-5-9, August–September 2006. Cana and its name, and the dust jacket.
  • Robert Fitzgerald, S.J., “Father Ed and A.A.’s Bill W.” Catholic Digest, April 1991, as transcribed at silkworth.net.
  • Glenn C., Heroes of Early Black AA: Their Stories and Their Messages. Hindsfoot Foundation, 2017. Chapter 1, the AA-1 Group.
  • Alcoholics Anonymous (the Big Book). Works Publishing, 1939. Chapter 5 (Step Twelve, page 72).