Watch The Kitchen Table
B 1 2 3 4 5 6
Illustration · The hall of an old office building in the evening: an elevator standing open at a middle floor, its folding gate pulled back and the car lit, with the floor dial over the door pointing to 3. Not drawn from a photograph.

Daily Reflections · January 16

Hitting Bottom

AA’s first members were last-gasp cases. When drinkers with more left to lose began to come, the members learned to bring the bottom up to meet them.

Today’s reading

The reading for January 16 in Daily Reflections, AA’s book of short readings by members. Its passage comes from Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, page 24, near the end of the essay on Step One: a question about the bottom, and Bill W.’s answer to it.

This page doesn’t reprint it. Read it free at aa.org, then come back for the asks.

Read it at aa.org

Themes and asks

  1. Why it takes a bottom

    The passage answers its own question: the rest of the program only looks worth doing to someone with no way left.

    • What do you do now that you’d have refused to do while you were drinking?
    • Which Step still feels like something you’d rather skip?
  2. What held at first

    For the member who wrote the reflection, fear of going back was enough to hold on early. The Steps did the slower work after it.

    • What kept you away from a drink in your first weeks, if you’re honest?
    • Is it still what keeps you away today?
  3. A bottom of your own

    The essay, just before the passage, says AA learned that a drinker didn’t have to lose everything to hit bottom: the members could bring it up to meet him. Behind the words tells how that came about.

    • If you came in with plenty left to lose, what showed you where you were headed?
    • If you lost nearly everything first, what would you tell someone who hasn’t?

Behind the words

Raise the bottom

Today’s passage comes near the end of Bill W.’s essay on Step One in the Twelve and Twelve, his book of essays on the Steps and Traditions, published in 1953. The paragraphs just before it admit that the bottom had moved. In AA’s pioneering time, the essay says, only “the most desperate cases” could stomach the admission, and so the first edition of the Big Book, in 1939, “dealt with low-bottom cases only.”

Bill had counted them. In November 1937, sitting in Akron with Dr. Bob S., he reckoned that more than forty alcoholics were staying sober (October 29 tells that day). The hard core, sober a couple of years, were what he called “very grim, last-gasp cases.”

Then, as Bill told it in his talks at AA’s twentieth-anniversary convention in St. Louis in 1955, the newcomers began to change. In the 1940s younger people started coming in, and people who still had “jobs and homes and health and even good social standing.” The essay adds “even two cars in the garage.” How was someone like that to admit his life had become unmanageable?

The members’ answer, in the essay’s words, was “to raise the bottom the rest of us had hit to the point where it would hit them.” In the same talks he called it “a conscious technique of ‘raising the bottom’ and hitting them with it.” A newcomer who could see he already had the main symptoms, he said, didn’t have to lose the rest before he hit bottom. How the old-timers showed him is the essay’s next sentence, and January 18’s story.

In 1955 the Big Book’s second edition gave such members a part of their own. Bill did most of the work on its stories himself, AA’s newsletter Box 4-5-9 recalled in 2001, and sorted them under three headings: “Pioneers of A.A.,” “They Stopped in Time” and “They Lost Nearly All.” The middle one was “a new category in 1955.” In the book today, that part’s introduction ends by summing up what its writers found: “Actually, the bottom came up and hit us.”

More on the young members who were told they hadn’t drunk enough yet: Under thirty-five, in The Only Requirement. On the count of November 1937: The barest majority, in By the Carload.

How far down they came from

Who came into AA and how far down they had gone, in AA’s own accounts, in the order of the years they describe, with today’s essay ringed. Today’s passage isn’t quoted. The tags and short lines are this page’s.

  1. November 1937The count

    Bill W. and Dr. Bob, in Akron

    “very grim, last-gasp cases”

    The hard core of the forty or more then sober, as Bill remembered them in 1955.

  2. 1939The first book

    The Big Book

    “low-bottom cases only”

    As the Step One essay described it in 1953: a book written when the members were few.

  3. The 1940sHigher up

    The newcomers

    “younger folks began to appear”

    And with them people with jobs, homes and their health, as Bill told it in 1955.

  4. 1953Today’s essay

    Bill W., on Step One

    “to raise the bottom”

    The paragraph just before today’s passage. The sentence after it is January 18’s.

  5. 1955A part of their own

    The Big Book, second edition

    “a new category in 1955”

    “They Stopped in Time,” one of three parts, between the pioneers and “They Lost Nearly All.” Box 4-5-9’s words, 2001.

Threads

Each one opens the calendar with its days lit up.

Sources
  • Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions. AA Grapevine and Alcoholics Anonymous Publishing, 1953. Step One. Page 24, which the reading cites, and the paragraphs before it.
  • Alcoholics Anonymous Comes of Age. Alcoholics Anonymous Publishing, 1957. “Recovery: The First Legacy” (the count of November 1937) and “Service: The Third Legacy” (the newcomers of the 1940s and raising the bottom), from Bill W.’s talks at St. Louis, 1955.
  • Alcoholics Anonymous (the Big Book). Works Publishing, 1939; second edition, 1955; fourth edition, AA World Services, 2001. The Preface (the three parts of stories) and the introduction to Part II, “They Stopped in Time.”
  • Box 4-5-9, October–November 2001, “Big Book Fourth Edition — Reflects Today’s Diverse Membership” (aa.org), on the second edition.
  • Daily Reflections. AA World Services, 1990. January 16 · aa.org

Something wrong here? A date, a name, a quotation? Let me know

Daily Reflections is AA’s book of readings for every day of the year, each written by a member about a favorite passage from AA’s literature. A Daily Reprieve gives each day questions to sit with and the story behind its words.