Daily Reflections · January 18
Would a Drink Help?
In 1945 AA’s magazine asked members when each thing in their drinking had first happened. Their answers put about ten and a half years between losing control and admitting it.
Today’s reading
The reading for January 18 in Daily Reflections, AA’s book of short readings by members. Its passage comes from Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, page 23, in the essay on Step One: one sentence on what older members could show a newcomer from their own past.
This page doesn’t reprint it. Read it free at aa.org, then come back for the asks.
Read it at aa.orgYour screen will stay on while Chairing is showing.
Themes and asks
-
Further back than it seemed
The passage, from the essay on Step One, is about what older members could show a newer one from their own past: where the drinking had really been heading, and how early.
- Looking back, when did your drinking first get away from you?
- How long was it before you said so, even to yourself?
-
A reason for every drink
The member who wrote the reflection keeps watch today for one thought: that the drinking is under control at last. Back then, small troubles were reason enough to pour one, and none of them got settled that way.
- What did you once tell yourself a drink would help with?
- What does “I’ve got it handled” sound like in your head today?
-
Medicine
Read beside today’s title: the men in the history below began, on average, to take a drink first thing in the morning, as a kind of medicine, a couple of years after they lost control. The pairing is this page’s own.
- What did you use a drink to treat: worry, fear, a bad day?
- What do you reach for now when the day goes wrong?
-
On paper
In 1945 Grapevine readers set down their own drinking histories, age by age, and mailed them in, as Behind the words tells. Doing the same for yourself is this page’s suggestion.
- If you marked the age each thing first happened, which one would surprise you?
- Who could you go over it with?
Behind the words
Ten and a half years
Today’s passage is about what an older member’s drinking can show a newer one, looked at again from sober. In April 1945, years before the essay was written, the Grapevine, AA’s monthly magazine, asked its readers to do that on paper. Its front page carried thirty-six questions under the headline “Big Light Can Be Shed on Alcoholism If A.A.s Fill This In and Return to Grapevine.” Beside each, a member was to write the age at which it had first happened.
Question four asked, “Begin to lose control of drinking?” Question thirty-four, near the end: “Admit to yourself that your drinking was beyond control?” When the forms came back, the editors asked E. M. Jellinek, a scientist at Yale, to work through them. He used 98, all from men, and in 1946 published what he found as a drinking history in phases.
The two answers lay far apart. On average the men had first lost control, in the questionnaire’s sense, at 27.6, and first admitted it to themselves at 38.1, about ten and a half years later (“11 years,” Jellinek rounded it). In between, as Jellinek read the forms, came a habit of finding a good reason for every drunk, and then the morning drink, taken as “a kind of self-prescribed medicine.”
Jellinek had faulted the questionnaire’s design. On the admission, though, he sided with AA: “Alcoholics Anonymous are right in attributing great significance to this self-admission.” As long as a drinker’s excuses still held up, he wrote, the man couldn’t sincerely feel he had a disease that needed treating. He warned, too, that these were averages, and that the order of events wasn’t the same for every man.
More on the questionnaire and Jellinek’s phases: Big light, in An Illness of This Sort. On the magazine’s first year: Ink-stained wretches, in Jittery and Alone.
Ten and a half years, on average
The 98 men’s drinking histories in order, as Jellinek summed them up in 1946, with the average age at each step. The gold-edged step is the one a look back is meant to find.
- About 25 · BlackoutsGaps in memory after drinking. The first mostly came before the men were alcoholics, and Jellinek read them as a warning.
- 27.6 · Loss of controlMeaning to have a couple, and ending up drunk. Jellinek made this the basic phase.
- Two years on · Good reasonsEvery drunk, the drinker told himself, had a good reason behind it.
- About 30 · The morning drinkA drink first thing, to get going.
- 31.8 · BendersDrunk for more than a day, whatever the work or the family.
- 38.1 · Admitting itTo himself, that his drinking was beyond control, about ten and a half years after he had lost it.
- 40.7 · The lowest pointWhat each man called his lowest point. About half, Jellinek reckoned, had reached it within the past year and been in AA a year at most.
Sources
- Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions. AA Grapevine and Alcoholics Anonymous Publishing, 1953. Step One. Page 23, which the reading cites.
- AA Grapevine, Volume I, Number 11, April 1945, page 1: the questionnaire “Big Light Can Be Shed on Alcoholism If A.A.s Fill This In and Return to Grapevine,” from the scan at silkworth.net. Jellinek’s paper dates it May 1945.
- E. M. Jellinek, “Phases in the Drinking History of Alcoholics: Analysis of a Survey Conducted by the Official Organ of Alcoholics Anonymous,” Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol 7 (1946), pp. 1–88, from the copy at aaagnostica.org.
- Daily Reflections. AA World Services, 1990. January 18 · aa.org
Something wrong here? A date, a name, a quotation? Let me know
Daily Reflections is AA’s book of readings for every day of the year, each written by a member about a favorite passage from AA’s literature. A Daily Reprieve gives each day questions to sit with and the story behind its words.