Watch The Kitchen Table
Illustration · A boardroom in the evening, after the meeting, seen from the head of a long table: a gavel lying on its side by its block, papers left at the places, and a leather armchair standing in the row with the plain chairs. Not drawn from a photograph.

Daily Reflections · January 21

Serving My Brother

Today’s passage comes from a lawyer who wasn’t an alcoholic: Bernard B. Smith, who chaired AA’s board through its first six Conferences, then stepped aside.

Today’s reading

The reading for January 21 in Daily Reflections, AA’s book of short readings by members. Its passage comes from Alcoholics Anonymous Comes of Age, Bill W.’s history of AA’s first twenty years, page 279, in a talk by Bernard B. Smith, one of AA’s nonalcoholic trustees: a few sentences on the spirit in which a sober member meets a newcomer.

This page doesn’t reprint it. Read it free at aa.org, then come back for the asks.

Read it at aa.org

Themes and asks

  1. Beside, not above

    The passage, from Bernard B. Smith’s talk, is about the footing a sober member meets a drinking one on.

    • When you talk with someone newer, what do you lead with: what you know, or what you were?
    • What part of your own story would put you beside them?
  2. The first time it’s said

    Just before the passage, Smith points to an earlier moment than a first share at a meeting: a man admitting it to his sponsor, at his lowest. He thought that one might count for even more.

    • Who first heard you say it?
    • Who might be waiting for a chance to say it to you?
  3. Stepping aside

    At the end of the same talk, Smith gives up the chair he had held since 1951. Leaving an office, he said, isn’t leaving AA; the one who goes keeps helping alongside everyone else.

    • What job in your group have you held long enough to hand on?
    • Whom could you help take it over?
  4. A friend from outside

    The passage a member picked for today is a nonalcoholic’s. Read beside the title, that suggests the brotherhood isn’t only for alcoholics: Smith said AA had become a way of life for him too. That reading is this page’s own.

    • Who outside AA has helped you stay sober?
    • What have you learned from someone whose story isn’t yours?

Behind the words

A friend at the head of the table

Today’s passage wasn’t written by Bill W., or by any alcoholic. They come from Bernard B. Smith, a New York lawyer who sat on AA’s board of trustees as one of its nonalcoholic members. AA Comes of Age (1957) prints his talk near its end, and says it was put together from what he told the first six General Service Conferences, which he chaired, from 1951 to 1956.

In the talk he remembers the afternoon a friend in AA brought Bill to his office, and the evening they spent together after. AA needed a lawyer for its foundation’s papers, but Smith took away more than a client: “in some mysterious way I was ready for Bill’s message.” Pass It On gives his years as a trustee as 1944 to 1956, and Arthur S.’s timeline has him joining in June 1944. Bill’s own history puts it later, about three years before 1950.

When Bill pressed for a conference of delegates from the groups, most of the board saw no need. Bill’s history says Smith and “one or two of the others” shared his worry; Pass It On and Bill’s secretary, Nell Wing, make Smith the only one. In 1950 he brought the trustees round, and Bill called him “the architect of the General Service Conference.”

After the sixth Conference, in April 1956, he resigned the chair. Nobody had asked him to, he said; he went because no one should hold an office in AA indefinitely, and he had long warned against a “proprietary right to serve.” “No one who is a part of A.A., as I feel I have been, steps out. He just steps aside.” The talk closes on a single regret, about how little he felt he had done.

In July 1970 Bill was too ill to give the main talk at AA’s convention in Miami Beach, and Smith was called down from New York in his place. Wing helped him rework “a conference talk of his from previous years.” On August 1, less than a month later, he died. Bill, too ill to go to the services, wrote: “Bern never was an outsider—not really.”

More on how the trustees came round: A standing vote, in Rule 62, and on AA’s nonalcoholic chairmen: Class A and Class B, in Trusted Servants.

A talk of paradoxes

The paradoxes Smith names in his talk, in the order he gives them. The gold-edged one is today’s passage.

  1. Owning the nameMembers call themselves alcoholics only once they’ve stopped drinking, just when the world stops seeing them that way.
  2. Today’s passageThe spirit in which a sober member goes to a drinking one. Read it at aa.org.
  3. Enslaved by alcohol?He doubts the phrase: drink, he says, was a way out of another bondage, to the false goals of a materialist age.
  4. The weakest linkAA’s chain gains strength, he says, by reaching the drinkers it hasn’t reached yet.
  5. Leaving for loveHis last: he resigns as chairman because he cares for AA, so that no one comes to own a place in it.

Threads

Each one opens the calendar with its days lit up.

Sources
  • Alcoholics Anonymous Comes of Age. Alcoholics Anonymous Publishing, 1957. “A Friend Looks at Alcoholics Anonymous”: Bernard B. Smith, “The Individual, A.A., and Society,” based on his talks at the first six General Service Conferences; page 279, which the reading cites. And “Service: The Third Legacy” (the trustees and the Conference, 1946–1950).
  • Pass It On. AA World Services, 1984. Chapters 20 and 21 (the Conference, and his years as a trustee) and 25 (Miami, 1970).
  • Nell Wing, Grateful to Have Been There. Parkside, 1992; second edition, Hazelden, 1998. Chapter 1, “Miami, January 1971,” page 5.
  • The Language of the Heart. AA Grapevine, 1988. Bill W., “Bernard B. Smith,” October 1970.
  • Arthur S., A Narrative Timeline of AA History, 2009. The entry for June 1944.
  • Daily Reflections. AA World Services, 1990. January 21 · aa.org

Something wrong here? A date, a name, a quotation? Let me know

Daily Reflections is AA’s book of readings for every day of the year, each written by a member about a favorite passage from AA’s literature. A Daily Reprieve gives each day questions to sit with and the story behind its words.