Watch The Kitchen Table
Illustration · A consulting room above a lake on a spring morning: a closed doctor’s bag at the end of the desk, a blank prescription pad and a pen, an inkwell, and the lake and the mountains through the open window. Not drawn from a photograph.

Daily Reflections · January 9

An Act of Providence

A doctor in Zurich told Rowland H. that doctors had nothing more to offer him, and the news traveled from him to Ebby T. to Bill W.

Today’s reading

The reading for January 9 in Daily Reflections, AA’s book of short readings by members. Its passage comes from Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, page 21, in the essay on Step One: one long sentence about how deep the obsession went.

This page doesn’t reprint it. Read it free at aa.org, then come back for the asks.

Read it at aa.org

Themes and asks

  1. Hard to say

    The passage owns how hard the admission is: the drinker’s own mind has been bent past anything a person could straighten alone.

    • What part of that is still hard for you to say out loud?
    • Whom did you first say it to?
  2. Before I believed

    The member who wrote the reflection looks back and sees care at work in their life well before they could accept any spiritual idea at all.

    • Looking back, where do you see help arriving before you asked for it?
    • What did you call it at the time?
  3. The verdict

    Read beside the history below: the man in AA’s story who was told that doctors could do no more for him took it as a place to start. That pairing is this page’s own.

    • What hard verdict about yourself turned out to be a beginning?
    • Is there one you’re still treating as the end?
  4. One phone call

    The member who wrote the reflection marks the moment they telephoned AA, with everything that mattered gone, as the moment things changed.

    • What was your first contact with AA, and who answered?
    • Who might be one call away from theirs today?

Behind the words

Zurich, 1926

The essay’s verdict had been handed down before, to one man, by a doctor. Rowland H., of a Rhode Island family of mill owners, had tried sanitariums and doctors at home. In the spring of 1926 he went to Zurich to be treated by the psychiatrist Dr. Carl Jung.

AA’s books tell what came next. He finished the treatment full of confidence and was soon drunk again. When he went back, Jung told him there was nothing more that doctors could do for him. Now and then, though, alcoholics had recovered through what the Big Book calls “vital spiritual experiences.”

Rowland said he believed in God already. That wasn’t enough, Jung said; he should join a religious movement and hope. Rowland found the Oxford Group, and in the summer of 1934 he carried what he’d found to Ebby T. in Vermont. That November Ebby carried it to Bill W. in Brooklyn.

In 1961 Bill wrote to Jung to thank him, calling Jung’s frank verdict on Rowland “the first foundation stone” of AA. Jung, in the last year of his life, wrote back that he had held something back from Rowland. Such an experience, he wrote, might come “by an act of grace,” through honest company with friends, or through learning that goes past reason alone. Rowland, he thought, had taken the second way.

The 1926 date comes from research newer than AA’s books. Bill remembered the visit as about 1931, and Pass It On followed him. In 2006 Amy Colwell Bluhm, working from family letters, put the start of Rowland’s time with Jung in 1926, and Court of Last Resort follows her.

More on Rowland in Zurich: The dope for me, in Court of Last Resort, and on how his year was found: Legacy. On Jung’s letter: Spiritus contra spiritum, in The Educational Variety.

The doctor’s answer, set down four times

Four accounts of the Zurich verdict and its date, in the order each was written.

  1. 1939The Big Book, “There Is a Solution”

    “You have the mind of a chronic alcoholic.”

    Told as a conversation, with no names and no date (later editions add Dr. Jung’s name).

  2. 1961Bill W. to Dr. Jung

    “…in short, a genuine conversion.”

    Bill’s memory of Rowland’s account. He puts the visit at about 1931.

  3. 1961Dr. Jung to Bill W.

    “…spiritus contra spiritum.”

    What he says he couldn’t tell Rowland: the craving was a thirst for wholeness.

  4. 2006Amy Colwell Bluhm, History of Psychology

    “…in the year 1926, rather than 1930 or 1931.”

    From letters in Rowland’s family’s papers, the year his time with Jung began.

Threads

Each one opens the calendar with its days lit up.

Sources
  • Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions. AA Grapevine and Alcoholics Anonymous Publishing, 1953. Step One. Page 21, which the reading cites.
  • Alcoholics Anonymous (the Big Book). Works Publishing, 1939; fourth edition, AA World Services, 2001. “There Is a Solution.”
  • Pass It On. AA World Services, 1984. Chapters 5 and 6 (Rowland H., Jung and Ebby).
  • The Language of the Heart. AA Grapevine, 1988. “The Bill W.–Carl Jung Letters,” January 1963, and “Dr. Jung, Dr. Silkworth, and AA,” January 1968.
  • Amy Colwell Bluhm, “Verification of C. G. Jung’s Analysis of Rowland Hazard and the History of Alcoholics Anonymous,” History of Psychology 9, no. 4 (2006), pages 313–324.
  • Daily Reflections. AA World Services, 1990. January 9 · aa.org

Something wrong here? A date, a name, a quotation? Let me know

Daily Reflections is AA’s book of readings for every day of the year, each written by a member about a favorite passage from AA’s literature. A Daily Reprieve gives each day questions to sit with and the story behind its words.