Daily Reflections · November 27
The Perils of the Limelight
Today’s paragraph comes from Bill W.’s essay on Tradition Eleven, written after years of asking reporters, and some of AA’s own members, to keep names out of the news.
Today’s reading
The reading for November 27 in Daily Reflections, AA’s book of short readings by members. Its passage comes from Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions, page 182, in the essay on Tradition Eleven.
This page doesn’t reprint it. Read it free at aa.org, then come back for the asks.
Read it at aa.orgYour screen will stay on while Chairing is showing.
Themes and asks
-
Nobody after a name
The passage is about reporters, whom the essay, just before it, calls doubters by trade, and what won them over: nobody in AA was trying to get famous.
- Who is still watching your sobriety the way a reporter would, waiting to see if it’s real? What would win them over?
- When you talk about AA to someone outside it, does it sound like a sales pitch or like your life?
-
Let your life say it
The essay leaves AA’s praise to its friends. The member who wrote the reflection, speaking for themselves, puts a changed life ahead of self-promotion.
- Who first carried AA to you, and what had you noticed about their life before they said a word?
- Is there something good you’re doing that would lose something if you posted about it?
-
Practice, not a rule
The member links anonymity with humility, and humility with keeping pride in check. Read beside today’s title, that makes anonymity less a rule than a practice, kept a little every day.
- Where do you still want credit for your recovery: the years, the service, the story?
- What could you do for someone this week that nobody would ever find out about?
-
Your group in public
Read beside Behind the words: AA had to ask editors to keep its members’ names out, and it still does. Now anyone with a phone can publish.
- If a reporter called your group, or a member wanted to film a meeting, would anyone know what to say?
- When you post about recovery, whose faces and names are in it, and did they agree?
Behind the words
Trained doubters
Today’s paragraph sits in the middle of Bill W.’s essay on Tradition Eleven, in the Twelve and Twelve, published in 1953. Just before it, he credits the reporters who had carried AA’s story, doubters by trade, and says many of them had become its friends. Just after it, he admits that for a time the press valued AA’s anonymity more than some members did. At one point about a hundred were breaking it in public. The office wrote to editors all over the continent, and the papers began cutting members’ names and pictures out of AA stories.
Editors hadn’t always given way. Early in 1941, as the Saturday Evening Post readied Jack Alexander’s article on AA, it asked for photographs. The office said no. The magazine answered, in effect, that without pictures there would be no story. The office gave in. Nell Wing told the story to a state convention in Massachusetts in 1983. She had joined the office in 1947 and in time became its archivist. It was, she said, the office’s “first and only officially sanctioned” break of anonymity.
Later in the 1940s, as she remembered it, reporters were caught in the middle. AA’s offices had asked them to leave out full names and pictures. But well-known members were announcing their membership in public. Among them were an entertainer and a New York radio announcer. The press, she said, was as confused as most of the members.
AA still writes to the press. Its letter to the media of January 2026, posted at aa.org, thanks reporters for keeping members anonymous. It asks them to name a member by first name and last initial only, and to show no face that could be recognized.
More on the office’s letters to editors: The short form, in Rule 62. On the Post’s photographs: A bunch of actors, in A Bunch of Actors. Where AA drew the line, from the group to the radio: First names only, in Keep Coming Back.
The press, four times
Bill W. told how reporters came round at least four times, in AA’s magazine, the Grapevine, and in the Twelve and Twelve, over eleven years. In order, with today’s essay marked. The lines are this page’s, apart from the quotations.
-
1946The Grapevine, March
Nearly every reporter, Bill wrote, starts out grumbling that a story without names is hard to write, and drops the grumble once he finds people who want nothing for themselves. Their sincerity makes him a friend.
-
1953The Twelve and TwelveToday’s essay
“trained doubters that they are”
The reporters, just before today’s paragraph. Just after it come the hundred members who broke anonymity, and the editors who cut their names.
-
1955The Grapevine, January
“proof positive that AA is on the square”
Now it’s the editors explaining. They give AA extra space, Bill wrote, because they trust it, and they trust it because it never puts its own people forward.
-
1957The Grapevine, October
“couldn’t imagine doing business without full names and pictures”
The average reporter, as Bill remembered him, until he heard why. By now, Bill wrote, editors were often the ones talking eager members out of being named.
Sources
- Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions. AA Grapevine and Alcoholics Anonymous Publishing, 1953. The essay on Tradition Eleven.
- The Language of the Heart. AA Grapevine, 1988. Bill W., “Our Anonymity Is Both Inspiration and Safety,” March 1946; “Why Alcoholics Anonymous Is Anonymous,” January 1955; and “Press, Radio, Television,” October 1957, first printed in the AA Grapevine.
- Nell Wing, Grateful to Have Been There: My Forty-two Years with Bill and Lois, and the Evolution of Alcoholics Anonymous. Second edition, Hazelden, 1998. Appendix A, “Anonymity,” her talk at Amherst, Massachusetts, July 29, 1983.
- aa.org, “Anonymity Letter to Media,” January 2026.
- Daily Reflections. AA World Services, 1990. November 27 · aa.org
Something wrong here? A date, a name, a quotation? Let me know
Daily Reflections is AA’s book of readings for every day of the year, each written by a member about a favorite passage from AA’s literature. A Daily Reprieve gives each day questions to sit with and the story behind its words.