Daily Reflections · January 10
United We Stand
In 1937 Dr. Silkworth told other doctors that an alcoholic’s body doesn’t take alcohol like other people’s, and wrote up a patient who had gathered more than fifty men.
Today’s reading
The reading for January 10 in Daily Reflections, AA’s book of short readings by members. Its passage comes from Alcoholics Anonymous, the Big Book, page 30, at the start of the chapter “More About Alcoholism”: three sentences on where recovery begins.
This page doesn’t reprint it. Read it free at aa.org, then come back for the asks.
Read it at aa.orgYour screen will stay on while Chairing is showing.
Themes and asks
-
All the way down
The passage asks for an admission that reaches the innermost self, and calls the hope of drinking like other people something to be broken.
- Where do you still half-believe you could drink the way other people do?
- What has that belief cost you before?
-
Pushed or pulled
The member who wrote the reflection lists what brings people in, a spouse, a court, a private hunch, and then the fellowship they find once they’re there.
- What got you through the door the first time?
- What keeps you coming back now?
-
All in one boat
The member pictures the fellowship as people adrift together, who reach land only by working together.
- Whom are you pulling alongside this week?
- Who might be waiting for a hand?
-
Broken, not doubted
The passage doesn’t ask for the idea of drinking like others to be doubted or set aside, but broken. Read beside the history below, a doctor’s evidence was one hammer; that pairing is this page’s own.
- What finally broke that idea for you: an event, a person, a fact?
- What keeps it from growing back?
Behind the words
Case V
Today’s passage asks the alcoholic to give up the idea of being like other drinkers. In March and April 1937 a doctor set out the difference for other doctors. Dr. William D. Silkworth, of Towns Hospital in New York, published two papers in the Medical Record.
The first, on March 17, argued that true alcoholism is an allergy: the alcoholic’s body reacts to alcohol as other people’s doesn’t, and the craving starts only with a drink. What follows, he wrote, “can not be duplicated in what we may call the ‘normal’ or nonallergic drinker.” Medicine doesn’t call it an allergy now, but the line he drew is the one the passage asks members to see.
The second, on April 21, set out his treatment, with five cases. Case V was a broker who had made up to $25,000 a year and was now living on his wife’s earnings. He came in with two philosophy books under his arm, and after treatment took up what Silkworth called “moral psychology.” Now he spent some of his income on helping others, and had gathered “a group of over fifty men” who had stopped drinking too.
The paper names nobody. But Pass It On has Bill W. arriving at Towns in December 1934 carrying two books on philosophy, as Silkworth remembered, and Silkworth’s biographer, Dale Mitchel, gives Bill’s Towns case number as 1152: the number the paper gives Case V. Two years later, Silkworth’s letter, “The Doctor’s Opinion,” opened the Big Book.
More on the two papers: The papers, in The Little Doctor, and his letter in the book: The Doctor’s Opinion. On the words doctors used: A far safer term, in An Illness of This Sort.
The difference, set down three times
Dr. Silkworth on the alcoholic and the other drinker, in the order he wrote it.
-
1937“Alcoholism as a Manifestation of Allergy,” March 17
“After the first drink, and only then…”
…does the craving start. The drinker who has a few a day for years never ends up on a spree.
-
1937“Reclamation of the Alcoholic,” April 21
“The final cure rests with themselves.”
Drying out ends the craving but doesn’t cure it, so no drinking at all afterward. Then five cases, the last of them Case V.
-
1939“The Doctor’s Opinion,” the Big Book
“…never occurs in the average temperate drinker.”
The craving, he wrote, belongs to the alcoholic alone, as he had suggested a few years before. Today’s passage follows two chapters on.
Sources
- Alcoholics Anonymous (the Big Book). Works Publishing, 1939: “The Doctor’s Opinion” and “More About Alcoholism”; fourth edition, AA World Services, 2001. Page 30, which the reading cites.
- W. D. Silkworth, “Alcoholism as a Manifestation of Allergy,” Medical Record, March 17, 1937. Reprint, National Library of Medicine.
- W. D. Silkworth, “Reclamation of the Alcoholic,” Medical Record, April 21, 1937. Reprint, National Library of Medicine.
- Pass It On. AA World Services, 1984. Chapter 5 (Bill’s last arrival at Towns).
- Dale Mitchel, Silkworth: The Little Doctor Who Loved Drunks. Hazelden, 2002. Chapter 3 (Bill W.’s case number).
- Daily Reflections. AA World Services, 1990. January 10 · aa.org
Something wrong here? A date, a name, a quotation? Let me know
Daily Reflections is AA’s book of readings for every day of the year, each written by a member about a favorite passage from AA’s literature. A Daily Reprieve gives each day questions to sit with and the story behind its words.